Assembling India’s Constitution: A New Democratic History

Authors

  • Prashant Pippal Jawaharlal Nehru University Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.66830/k0jx6x91

Keywords:

Constitution-making, Constituent Assembly, state formation, archival historiography, constituent power , sovereignty

Abstract

Rohit De and Ornit Shani's Assembling India's Constitution: A New Democratic History (2025) intervenes decisively in the historiography of Indian constitution-making, displacing Granville Austin's canonical narrative of elite deliberation within the Constituent Assembly. Drawing on petitions, memoranda, civic resolutions, and organisational correspondence, the authors reconstruct constitution-making as an "organic process" shaped by diverse publics, from the Balkan-ji-Bari's children's rights charter to princely-state Praja Mandal mobilisations. This review argues that the book's central conceptual move is to present the state as an assembled political formation, negotiated between institutional actors and mobilised constituencies rather than a pre-constituted sovereign authority, while simultaneously revealing the state's internal fragmentation through judicial lobbying for autonomy and provincial legislatures' complaints of centralisation. Methodologically, the book's archival expansion redistributes agency beyond "founding fathers," reframing figures like B.N. Rau through "technocratic cosmopolitanism" and exposing strategic appropriations of minority discourse across caste groups. However, the review identifies a persistent conceptual limitation: radical proposals (right to recall, disability protections, popular rule in Delhi) were sidelined, raising unresolved questions about whether participation constituted co-equal authorship or merely bounded consultation. The review concludes that the book's democratic reorientation, despite its theoretical restraint on sovereignty and constituent power, transforms constitutional historiography and opens essential debates for future scholarship.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-14

How to Cite

Assembling India’s Constitution: A New Democratic History. (2026). Critical Journal of Social Sciences, 2(2). https://doi.org/10.66830/k0jx6x91